March 04, 2008
United Opportunity
Pop/Rock, Alternative/Indie Rock, Adult Alternative Pop/Rock, Celtic Rock

Album Review

Just in time for the fifth anniversary of the U.S. invasion of Iraq, with American fatalities approaching 4,000, along with uncounted Iraqi casualties, New York-based Irish-American rock band Black 47, led by singer/songwriter Larry Kirwan, devote an entire album to the subject. It's not as unlikely a theme as one might suppose, since, as Kirwan reveals in a sleeve note, the album is "written from the viewpoint of Black 47 fans who have served over there." Thus, the various first-person stories in the lyrics give the songs an eyewitness perspective of the "terrible war" that most affects the sort of working-class Americans who, through a combination of patriotism and career aspiration, have joined either the military or even just the National Guard and found themselves serving in Iraq. The music combines hard rock with R&B and Celtic strains in a style reminiscent of the '80s sound of Dexys Midnight Runners. Kirwan is not above borrowing tunes, as he does in rewriting the traditional "Sloop John B" for the leadoff song, "Stars & Stripes," even retaining the refrain of "I want to go home." He also mixes in 12-bar blues structures ("Sadr City"), while his vocals often take on a rap-like cadence. It's all in the service of providing a grunt's eye view of people actually doing the fighting, people who, like soldiers everywhere throughout history, mostly just hope they can come out of the war alive and in one piece. Kirwan leaves no doubt that he is against the war, nor that he supports the troops, but his main concern is with telling the stories of the Black 47 fans who would rather be in a bar in Brooklyn rocking out to their favorite band than patrolling the dangerous streets of Baghdad.
William Ruhlmann, Rovi

Track Listing

  1. Stars and Stripes
  2. Downtown Baghdad Blues
  3. Sadr City
  4. Sunrise on Brooklyn
  5. No Better Friend...
  6. Ballad of Cindy Sheehan
  7. The Last One to Die
  8. The Fighting 69th (On the Road to the Airport)
  9. Battle of Fallujah
  10. Ramadi
  11. Southside Chicago Waltz
  12. Whatever...
purchase full album