The British arm of the Universal label marked the 60th anniversary of the release of the film Holiday Inn in 1942 with this 2002 CD pairing the "soundtrack" (actually, studio) recordings associated with the film and those for the 1954 movie White Christmas, which is sometimes cited as a partial remake of the earlier picture. (Both films are buddy pictures featuring
Bing Crosby; both concern a sort of inn-cum-nightclub in New England; both have song scores by
Irving Berlin; and both boast the song "White Christmas.")
Crosby pairs with
Fred Astaire in Holiday Inn -- and with
Danny Kaye in White Christmas -- and it is
Crosby who dominates here, singing not only "White Christmas," but also memorable tunes including "Be Careful, It's My Heart" and "Count Your Blessings Instead of Sheep." (Reissue producer
Ken Barnes has substituted the actual soundtrack recording of "Easter Parade" here because, as annotator
Malcolm MacFarlane explains,
Crosby had a cold when he made the studio recording used on previous releases of
Holiday Inn.) The music from
White Christmas differs from what movie fans heard in the theater not only in that the actual performances are different, but also in that the casting had changed.
Rosemary Clooney, who co-starred, was contracted to a different record label and prohibited from appearing on the soundtrack album. So,
Peggy Lee stepped in instead. (Also,
Gloria Wood, who sang for Vera-Ellen in the film, was in turn replaced on the recording by
Trudy Stevens.)
Lee brings her own flair to songs like "Love You Didn't Do Right by Me," although her double-tracked version of the duet "Sisters" isn't a patch on the
Clooney studio recording, on which she sang with her own sister,
Betty Clooney. (The track is erroneously co-credited to
Stevens on this reissue; in fact,
Lee is singing with herself.) Not all of the music here is top-drawer
Berlin, but of course some is, and with a cast led by
Crosby and including
Astaire,
Kaye, and
Lee, there are some excellent performances, too.
–
William Ruhlmann, Rovi