In the wake of the recent, superb box set, it's hard to imagine a single disc being definitive of one of Britain's great folk singing groups. At best, you can touch on their different facets and legacy. But
Definitive Collection actually does a splendid job. There are the hymns, the traditional songs, and some of the permutations (
Lal and
Norma,
Mike, even the late
Peter Bellamy), as well as tracks by
Waterson:Carthy and
Blue Murder, who carry on the flame of the original
Watersons in many ways (especially
Blue Murder, which is essentially
Waterson:Carthy plus
Barry Coope,
Jim Boyes and
Lester Simpson). The tracks are from their
"Topic" albums (which means, because of licensing, nothing from the original, wonderful
Bright Phoebus release is here), but all of those that are here are wonderful, and sung with such naturalness that they epitomize what folk singing should be about. There's no sense of premeditation about their performances. This is simply who they are, and their way of expressing themselves. It's not
Mighty River of Song, which really is definitive, but as an introduction to the
Watersons, and an overview of their massive achievements in folk music, this works excellently.
–
Chris Nickson, Rovi