The debut album by
the Cumberland Three was also an attempt by
Morris Levy's Roulette Records to get in on a piece of the folk-music action spurred by the success of
the Kingston Trio. The album compares very favorably with the work of
the Kingston Trio -- no less a figure than the latter group's co-founder,
Dave Guard (who was to be succeeded by Cumberland Trio co-founder
John Stewart), endorses
the Cumberland Three on the original jacket -- and may even be preferable to some listeners, because
the Cumberland Three don't let overt humor and comic relief play too large a role in their recordings. Not that they don't have fun, but they concentrate on the music, which ranges from traditional folk to faux Civil War songs and calypso-influenced numbers. The vocals are impeccable, and even more alluring as they aren't too perfect --
John Stewart's singing on "New Land" is rough-hewn and affecting in a very serious way, and the rousing follow-up, "Nine Hundred Miles," makes them a perfect match-up on the original album. The 1999 Collectors' Choice reissue has been extended with three bonus tracks, a surprisingly soulful version of Leadbelly's "Cotton Fields," a lyrical and touching "You Can Tell the World," and a slow but not too mournful "Old Dog Blue," all familiar songs from other venues that come to life anew here.
–
Bruce Eder, Rovi